Enemies of Promise: The NUT and Association of Teachers and Lecturers

If you can read this you are probably over fifty. Tiny snippets in tabloid papers sometimes offer accidental clues to major issues. At the bottom of a page in Metro, on Friday 6th September a few lines praised our improving education system. ‘Girls show they R the best’ said the top line. Happily ignoring how badly boys are doing.

The latest primary school SAT results show that while seventy percent of girls reached the ‘expected standard’ in reading, writing and maths,’ only sixty percent of boys did so. An overall figure gave a one percent improvement.

The paper and ‘school standards’ minister Nick Gibb are delighted. ‘It’s a testament to the hard work of pupils and teachers,’ said Gibb.

It certainly is and some of us would award no gold stars at all. But if girls are doing better, hey, that must be good. Better get with the zeitgeist as that is what state education in the UK is all about.

This Sunday, the 8th, is National Literacy Day. Let’s all celebrate a one percent increase in success along with Mr Gibb, and forget that England currently ranks bottom, twenty- third out of twenty- three among Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) nations, for teenage literacy. Those nations include Chile, Estonia, Hungary, Poland and Slovakia which have tiny economies compared to ours, and Mexico which is a failed state. We are the only one of the thirty- six OECD countries where the literacy of 16-24-year olds is lower that of people aged fifty-five and over. This is the first generation in history to be less literate than their grandparents.

Former education secretary Michael Gove rightly referred to elements among UK teachers as the ‘enemies of promise.’ As he tried to raise standards, he became aenathema to the NUT and Association of Teachers and Lecturers. ‘Gove’ became a meme for their hatred of the capitalist system.  

In the UK, unlike other countries literacy is about politics. Between 2009 and 2016 the general secretary of the NUT was Christine Blower a one-time London Assembly candidate for the ‘London Socialist Alliance,’ a Trotskyist coalition including the Socialist Workers Party.

The teaching unions have always denied that there are falling standards of literacy in the UK, and insist that international league tables are irrelevant. For years we’ve watched as teachers have been absurdly addicted to ideological teaching methods even if they don’t work. Teachers resisted the re-introduction of phonics, even though children were not learning to read with the ‘whole-word learning’ technique. We had the wife of the then Prime Minister, Glenys Kinnock, saying she was, ‘very left-wing about reading.’

Teachers or rather ‘facilitators’ as they preferred to be known clung to mixed ability teaching even though it brought down the brighter pupils. They still abhor learning by rote, long known to be effective for teaching times tables. When I taught in prison the staff sneered at African prisoners, far more able than the English inmates, because it was believed they’d been taught by rote and so, ‘were not creative enough.’ I was grateful that they, unlike the English lads, could concentrate and contribute, with a much wider vocabulary.

It’s doubtful that there are any conservative teachers in state schools now. I would characterise them as people who love their subject more than politics, yearn to impart knowledge by traditional methods, and cherish an ancient canon of knowledge which they want all pupils to share. Joe Baron wrote in The Spectator in 2016 that he’d lost his job as a teaching assistant after revealing he was, ‘The only right of centre teacher in the History department.’ He’d worried about the indoctrination of the pupils, particularly about the British Empire, with what seems to have been inaccurate information.

A poll before the last election showed that only eight percent of teachers were voting Tory. They probably gave that information secretly. According to Laura McInerny founder of ‘Teacher Tapp,’ an app trying to give a wider range of teachers ‘a voice,’  in 2017 sixty percent of teachers said they had voted Labour and  twelve percent Tory, ‘which,’ says McInerny, ‘might account for why Tory teachers say  they feel uneasy talking about politics in the staffroom.’

You Gov poll before the last election, found that 56% of headteachers were voting Labour. 

Teachers I know never mention their conservative politics or support for Brexit in the staff-room. Thanks to this addiction to Marxist post-modernism which insists that knowledge is relative and worse, ‘elitist,’ we now have an underclass of people who can’t wash their hands without diagrams, cannot recognised nutritious food or manage basic cooking for their families, let alone design a car engine. They know nothing of British geography, history or literature apart from The Handmaid’s Tale and To Kill A Mockingbird.

Ironically the Left now feel rather bitten by this; blaming the uneducated mass for Brexit. Joe Baron’s downfall came when, ‘After keeping schtum for two months,’ he challenged a colleague’s view that ‘Tory voters are all thick.’

As a nation we are now world famous for the shambles of Brexit. Some on both sides of that divide worry that if it ever happens the educated, diligent (European) workers will leave. No need to worry as they will soon be replaced by south east Asians who are more educated by the age of ten than many Brits by eighteen. They will fill the learning and skills gap and it will serve us right.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

12 Comments on Enemies of Promise: The NUT and Association of Teachers and Lecturers

  1. from Jane Kelly:

    ‘We had the wife of the then Prime Minister, Glenys Kinnock, saying she was, “very left-wing about reading”.’

    Remind me, when was Neil Kinnock Prime Minister?

  2. As a retired secondary school teacher, I don’t think I ever thought about a left v right wing view. I, like most of my colleagues just got on with the job as best we could. Michael McManus (above) is quite right.

  3. “It’s doubtful that there are any conservative teachers in state schools now.”

    There are still a few of us, Jane. Not many perhaps, but a smattering, who plug on as best we can despite the nonsense we witness.

    You’re right that we have to be careful when and how we express ourselves, but on various occasions I’ve had the pleasure of being approached by colleagues who’ve told me how grateful they were for something I’d said – at a staff meeting or Inset session, usually – which they agreed with but didn’t dare say themselves.

    This encouraged me enough that I got myself elected by my colleagues as a staff governor too, so perhaps there is hope for profession yet.

      • Well I actually no longer support the “Conservative and Unionist Party” myself – precisely because I am a (small ‘c’) conservative who’s watched the Tory Party betray everything I believe in that it ever once stood for – but your point is well taken Michael.

  4. What I find quite worrying is that some schools allow their children to watch BBC’s Newsround. I dread to think how the following are portrayed, when we know the BBC’s fixed positions on each:
    Donald Trump
    Climate Change

  5. One of the reasons why Remainers battle so hard over Brexit is that they know that a battle won on such a key terrain has huge implications for other areas, notably in education at primary, secondary and university levels. If 56 per cent of headteachers vote Labour, its about 90% for uni lecturers-all in the name of diversity of course.

    • It might be profitable to ask why political affiliations have changed over the last 50 years. Teachers like medics were overwhelmingly tory voters even when the unions were Communist run. I remember the despair: at annual conference there would be all these firebrand speeches and demands for strikes – all listened to with indifference by rows and rows of women delegates, knitting.
      There was not the continual carping, blaming schools for social ills, nor micromanagement in those days. There was also HMI – objective assessments of all factors affecting education, not Ofsted’s politicalised wool.
      Nurses and doctors no longer support Conservatives either. I believe the lawyer vote is still solid.

  6. I spent 20 years teaching the toughest teens who had been dumped by schools and 20 more training teachers and running post-graduate courses with substantial numbers of teachers from overseas. I can’t agree with much in this article.
    It’s true that the unions are run by leftists but part of the blame for that needs to be widely spread. Union elections involve a tiny minority, and failure to put in the time is why conservatives are underrepresented. On the NUT committee I served every other person was Communist Party or other fruitcake left.
    The international tables are so absurd they really can’t be taken at face value. Mexico? Come on.
    The so-called politics of reading. I defy anyone to give a single reason why Look and Say is leftier than Phonics. Teachers have always – just like parents – used whatever ways they can think of to teach reading and that is a mixture of sounding out and ‘learn this word on this flashcard’ for words like ‘ought’. The ‘controversy’ passed teachers by. I’m afraid the author has little acquaintance with teachers if she thinks they are anything other than hard-working, highly intelligent and committed to getting the best for the kids – especially those whose lives are ruined or neglected by our failure to ensure all children get a decent start in life. (Don’t anyone dare say, ‘That’s the responsibility of parents’.)

    I doubt standards have changed at all – girls always have done better than boys worldwide and will continue to do so. (XX beats XY okay?) What has changed recently is there’s less help for the weak and more resources are being moved from child to men in suits – ‘academies’ now have CEOs with all the benefits they bring with their managerialist bullshit and massive pay.

1 Trackbacks & Pingbacks

  1. Enemies of Promise: The NUT and Association of Teachers and Lecturers – Technical Politics